Choosing between a mud turtle and a musk turtle for a pet can be tough. Both have unique qualities that make them endearing.
Both mud and musk turtles are great pets, but musk turtles are often more aquatic and have a distinct musky odor, while mud turtles prefer shallower waters and are less odorous.
Keep reading for a closer look at their unique traits and how to choose the one that’s right for you.
Key Differences
| Mud Turtle | Musk Turtle | |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Typically smaller, usually up to 5 inches. | Slightly larger, can reach up to 6 inches. |
| Tank Size | At least 50 gallons | At least 60 gallons |
| Diet | Omnivorous, with a preference for meat. | Also omnivorous but may lean more towards plants. |
| Lifespan | up to 50 years | 30-50 years |
| Behavior | Can be more terrestrial, enjoying time on land. | Mostly aquatic and rarely leaves the water. |
| Odor | Less pronounced. | Emit a musky odor when threatened. |
| Habitat Preference | Prefer shallow waters with abundant vegetation. | Thrive in deeper, still waters. |
Which Is Easier To Care For?
Mud turtles, for instance, might be slightly easier for some due to their adaptability. They don’t require as deep a water setup as musk turtles, which could mean a smaller, potentially less expensive tank setup.
They enjoy a mix of land and water in their habitat, so you’ll have fun designing a space that mimics their natural environment. Their diet is pretty straightforward, leaning towards meat, but they’re not picky eaters.
On the flip side, musk turtles are fascinating creatures, especially for those who love aquatic life. They spend most of their time in the water, so you’ll need a tank that’s a bit more geared towards their swimming preferences.
The deeper water setup can be a bit more challenging, but it’s nothing a dedicated turtle owner can’t handle! And while their musky defense mechanism is unique, it’s not something you’d typically encounter unless they feel threatened.
How Bad Do Musk Turtles Smell?
First, musk odor is a defense mechanism, not a constant state of being, for these turtles. In a comfortable, stress-free environment, your musk turtle is unlikely to feel the need to release its musky scent. The smell is there, but it’s not perpetually in the air.
When they release their musk, yes, it’s noticeable, but it’s not overwhelming. It’s more akin to a strong, musky smell that lingers briefly before dissipating, especially in a well-ventilated area.
Final Thoughts
Both make fascinating pets, but they’ve got their differences.
Mud turtles are more laid-back, need shallower water, and are happy to chomp on some meat.
Musk turtles are for those who enjoy aquatic life, even though they might surprise you with a musky scent when startled.
Related Posts:
- Red-Eared Slider Vs Painted Turtle – Which Is Better?
- 4 Best Pet Turtles For Beginners (And What To Avoid)
- 7 Types Of Pet Turtles That Stay Small
- How Big Does A Musk Turtle Get?
Sources:
